This is one of the most common financial trade-offs for people in their thirties, and the honest answer is that it depends on your individual circumstances rather than a universal rule.
The case for prioritising your pension often centres on time. Starting or increasing pension contributions in your mid-thirties gives your money several decades to grow. Pension contributions also benefit from tax relief — meaning HMRC tops up what you put in — and if your employer matches contributions, not paying in enough to capture that match is effectively leaving part of your salary on the table.
The case for paying down your mortgage rests on the interest rate you are paying. A higher mortgage rate means every pound of overpayment delivers a guaranteed, risk-free return equal to that rate. Reducing your mortgage balance also lowers financial risk if your income changes.
Factors that typically come into the balance include: your mortgage interest rate versus the expected long-term return on pension investments; how many years remain on your mortgage; whether you have an employer pension match available; your current tax rate (higher-rate taxpayers receive more generous pension tax relief); and whether you have other financial buffers such as an emergency fund.
Many people in this position do a combination of both rather than choosing one entirely. There is no single correct split — it depends on your income, mortgage terms, pension arrangements, and longer-term goals.
A regulated independent financial adviser can model both options against your specific numbers and help you decide what balance makes sense for your situation.
Information only. This isn’t personal financial advice. For that, speak to a regulated adviser.